Site Content

Welcome! I’m Kyle, the owner of Collectibles By Kyle, based in central Indiana. My journey began back in 2004, sparked by my childhood Beanie Baby collection and a lifelong passion for Christmas and all things festive. What started as a simple hobby has grown over the years into a small business that allows me to share the joy of the holidays year-round!

By day, I’m part of the executive team at a credit union in the Indianapolis area, and by night (and weekends!), I run Collectibles By Kyle as my side gig — with the amazing help of my wife, Haley. Together, we juggle the business while being busy parents to two wonderful kids, who keep life exciting and full of joy.

At Collectibles By Kyle, we’re proud to offer competitive, market-based pricing, 5-star customer service, and a satisfaction guarantee with every order. Whether you’re looking for that perfect addition to your holiday collection or a nostalgic piece that brings back memories, our goal is to make every purchase feel special.

Thank you for supporting our small business and letting us share a bit of Christmas cheer with you — no matter the season! 

What we Sell

if you have heard of it, we have probably sold it! With thousands of items having been sold over the years, we have seen a wide range of collectibles. Brands such as Hallmark, Enesco, Department 56, Waterford Crystal, Willow Tree, Shiny Brite, Vintage Christmas, Carlton Cards, American Greetings, and so many more. While the focus remains on name brand, high quality collectibles, you will find various vintage and other unique finds mixed in with the holiday collections and ornaments we share. 

5-Star Customer Service Guaranteed!

Rest assured that when you buy from Collectibles By Kyle, your satisfaction is guaranteed. We work to resolve any issue that may come up and strive to have a returning customer base. We look forward to getting to know you and helping you find that next treasure to add to your collection!